Stoneleigh Park

A Timeless Oasis on the South Side of Westfield

t

Stoneleigh Park, nestled between Westfield Avenue and Rahway Avenue in south-central Westfield, is a true gem within the town. Dating from the early twentieth century, this small, picturesque development was thoughtfully designed to harness the area’s pre-existing natural beauty. The neighborhood was envisioned as an idyllic haven for commuting New York executives, as well as affluent Westfield businessmen and civic leaders seeking a serene and prosperous place to call home.

Development Pioneers

The visionaries behind Stoneleigh Park were H.B. Tremaine, president of the Aeolian Company and his cousin, C.M. Tremaine. They embarked on this project, crafting a neighborhood consisting of thirty single-family houses spread across approximately twenty acres of park-like property. Remarkably, two of these houses, including one on Dorian Road, became the residences of the Tremaine cousins themselves.

Architectural Evolution

Most of the original houses in Stoneleigh Park, designed in the Colonial Revival style, have retained their essence since their construction around 1904. In the 1920s, a second group of houses was erected, primarily in the Colonial Revival style, with some in the English Tudor style. A few additional houses in similar styles were added during the 1940s and 1950s. While many homes in the neighborhood maintain the size and scale of the original group, some exhibit features characteristic of their respective periods of construction.

Entrance and Park-Like Ambiance

Twin brick posts adorned with concrete ball finials grace the entrance to Stoneleigh Park, marking the beginning of a journey into this tranquil enclave. Each post bears a substantial octagonal iron lantern embellished with an “S” representing Stoneleigh. The iron rings that once closed off the entrance can still be observed. An alternate entrance at the opposite end of the park was closed in 1983 to discourage through traffic that could disrupt the neighborhood’s peace and quiet. The neighborhood’s irregularly shaped, generously sized lots, measuring at least 100′ x 200′, were designed to emphasize its park-like ambiance.

Stoneleigh Park features charming carriage-type lamps mounted on simple wooden posts, tasteful landscaping abundant with shrubs and trees, and all wiring discreetly buried underground. This meticulous attention to detail maintains the neighborhood’s cherished “park-like” atmosphere.

Historical Significance

The original section of the Stoneleigh Park Historic District earned a spot on the National Register of Historic Places in 1988. Today, the neighborhood stands as a peaceful, park-like haven, meticulously landscaped and maintained. The Tremaine cousins’ vision has not only come to life but has also endured the test of time, continuing to captivate residents and visitors alike.

Housing Market

Due to the small number of homes in Stoneleigh Park and the current lack of inventory, there are no current statistics.  The last two homes to sell 2 years ago, were around $1.5 million, but the market has risen since then.

Conclusion

Stoneleigh Park in Westfield, NJ, remains a testament to early twentieth-century upper middle-class living, thoughtfully designed to harmonize with the natural beauty of the area. This neighborhood, envisioned by H.B. Tremaine and C.M. Tremaine, continues to epitomize tranquility, prosperity, and timeless architectural charm. It offers residents a unique opportunity to embrace its rich history and architectural significance while enjoying the modern amenities and excellent nearby schools. Stoneleigh Park is a testament to the enduring appeal of a community that has preserved its original charm throughout the years.